MC6 Round 1 Results - Frozen Wheelchair

 
"Frozen Wheelchair"
(m6v-weel.zip)

by

Mikael Nzane
(Nzane)


This song competed in the veteran division of Music Contest 6, where it ranked in block 3.

Judge: North ,DTravis

Catchy tune...but outclassed. Theory is clean and efficient. Samples are of good quality...but I question some sample choices.

Judge: Schulze ,Markus

When I first listened to this song and at the end I saw that it was only three minutes and fifteen seconds long I didn't believe my eyes. I thought it was longer. Normally this is a bad sign, but not in this case. I really enjoyed listening to this song. Actually I don't know a lot bad things about it that I could criticize. Maybe there could have been one or two more different chord progressions, and the samples sound not very original, but they are used in a fairly original way (at least this is what I think. For different opinions you should ask the originality mafia). Apart from these two things there are no problems with this song and. The melodies are really nice and all in all it's a rather detailed work. One of my favourite tracks.

Judge: Rodriguez ,Daniel

This song is easy to hear, groovy, but it repeats the same schemes too much. It's not too long. All the samples are well choosen. Its ending is abrupt. It's maybe too simple (in its style) to earn a big score: the tracker could have showed more things in this entry. But it's one of the best I reviewed so far.

Judge: Tanase ,Adrian

Nice tracked, nice samples, not very good ideas and pretty repeating. Anyway I think it desirves a 65 overall (panning used well, a little of volume control, some echos...few progressive ideas)

Judge: Girard ,Marc

Weird Slap bass played too high, sounds like an old .MOD to me :) It's just a bit above fair.